OMG!!!! I can’t believe the whole “different ultimatum!” How bogus is that! That was one of the best parts! Ugh! I wish someone else was doing the scripts and all that stuff! OMG!!!
Oh ya and Sara, I hope they don’t cut her out. For one she was the whole reason Bella changed when she did. And Jacob imprints on her. That’s how he gets over her. And she’s one of the reasons the Volturi come back. So news flash. Get over it. Shes got to be there.

The marriage condition might come in to play in Eclipse because she tells him “yes” so i can understand it not being in Full Moon. The thing is that they cut to much of the book from the movie in Twilight ,and i’m sorry to say but because they did that it wasn’t as good as it could have been, and i just don’t wan’t to have to say that about the other three if they make Breaking Dawn. They just need to keep a hold of the thing that make the books good and keep them in the movies.

[quote=Sara]All fine by me. I just hope to God the filmakers have the sense to cut out Renesme from the story. Just turn her into a vampire and end it there. The forth book with Renesme ruined the whole series for me. I just pretend it was never written[/quote]wtf is your problem Breaking Dawn was awesome!!!!!!

why are they changing it? i want edward to say to bella that he will only turn her into a vampire if they marry. well cant wait for the movie cuz ima huge twilight fan. hope its good.

Taking the marriage condition out is the worse thing they could do to the movies… It will totally alter the rest of the movies… and its going to piss ALOT of people off!

I’m sorry but the condition in the end of the book is what the basis of the third book is based on. I think it is the dumbest thing in the world to cut that condition out

[quote=lostmymind]i hope they dont change it to much. i loved every bit of the books (all of them) and really hope nothing changes hope they keep it as close as they can.[/quote]
i know, i just hope that the ultamatinum isnt too different because i think its a really good cliff hanger for the next book… and i really love the books and i hate how hollywood just wants to change so much because the books are pretty perfect to me (:

[quote=danielle]I really don’t think that the marriage condition should have been changed. What else could they possibly have done to make it any better than what it already is? If they take away Edward’s marriage condition, that may only be one small thing that gets changed in the second story, but it’s gonna change way too much for Eclipse. The marriage condition is what the entire third book lingers on, which is why Bella comes up with her condition…. it’s all so dumb. But I guess if Stephenie Meyer is right there making sure the script stays as true to the book as possible, what more can you do. It’s hollywood, ya know.[/quote]
good point, i wish it would stay the same… whats the point of making the movies if everything is different? and obviously with reviews and stuff the books are doing just fine, great actually, so whats with the changes?

[quote=Sara]All fine by me. I just hope to God the filmakers have the sense to cut out Renesme from the story. Just turn her into a vampire and end it there. The forth book with Renesme ruined the whole series for me. I just pretend it was never written[/quote]
why would they cut out renesme? thats pointless… if they cut her out theres absolutely no point to breaking dawn. the only thing in the book would be the wedding and honeymoon pretty much… there would be no jacob inprinting, no volturi returns, and no point. its safe to say taking renesme out of breaking dawn would be the stupidest mistake hollywood could make… and it will not happen…

[quote=Tiffany]I cant even imagine what tehy would have changed the ultimatum to. I am already kind of disappointed by that fact, and i hope that whatever they change it to, its just as good. But if the new ultimatum changes the fact that they are to marry and concieve Renesmee, then i am going to be pretty upset. Renesmee makes the entire fourth novel.[/quote]
exactly… couldnt agree more… (:

i think changing Edward’s condition is utterly STUPID!!!
other changes dont bother me that much but his request of marriage a) slows down bella’s becoming a vampire b) emphasises the difference in culture between modern values and those of WW2 c) makes the whole this SO much more romantic as edward wants to be with her forever!!!
i know drugs are an issue with the rich and the famous but seriously they need to lay off the blow!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

this is going to ruin the movie!! without the marrriage the rest of eclipse will be different and confusing! there going to lose a lot of fans because of this!!!!!!!!! :(

[quote=Sara]All fine by me. I just hope to God the filmakers have the sense to cut out Renesme from the story. Just turn her into a vampire and end it there. The forth book with Renesme ruined the whole series for me. I just pretend it was never written[/quote]
Are yu stupid without Renesme theres no point to he fourth book and then if they just change her it would just ruin the whole book series. I think theyv made a mistake by changin the ultamatum because without the marriage whats the point to last two books if thats the case they may aswell just forget making any movies and not bring out New Moon if there not going to stick to the story line we all fell in love with its pointless. Personally if they have changed the film to much theyve just ruined it all for me and all the rest of the films, there just going to ruin it for everyone.

You stupid idiot who wrote the first one!!! First of all if your gonna rag on it spell her name right! It’s Renesmee!!!!!!! 2 e’s you dumb butt!!! She brought it all together and made it possible to bring Bella into the family without some one hating her aka Rosalie! Renesmee is the bomb! Like tick tick, I love her and i hope she becomes real and bites the crap out of u!

Hmm… Well, as opposed as I am to the movie straying from the book, I actually like the idea of Edward appearing to Bella when he ‘speaks’ to her…. In the book, it actually DOES describe things like his voice sounding frantic and him growling at in her head. As someone else said earlier, I always picture his face when I read these descriptions. So it would make since to actually show him in the movie, since we cannot read the descriptors that were in the book…. I like this idea a lot….
As for the conversation about the Breaking Dawn movie, I actually put it down and refused to pick it back up for 5 months I was so disgusted. However, there really is nothing they can cut out to fix it. Everything included that made in so terrible was necessary for the last ‘battle’….. *sigh*
… Rant over! =) Yay New Moon! lol

People HATE when the book is way different than the movie. Thats what happened in the new Harry Potter movie. I will be so disapointed if the movie isnt anything like the book. I wont even watch eclipse or anything if this movie is ruined. It would ruin the whole saga and the rest of the books!!

I’m not a big fan of them changing the story line that much. I loved each and every one of the books. If they have Edward using a different ultimatum then marriage then they will have to change the other two books in order to make it all fit. I think they should just leave it that he tells her he wont change her unless they get married. That’s the way the book was written and that’s how it should be in the movie.

i’ll be srsly angry if they change to much in the movie..jeesh keep it the way its supposed to be!
you’ll lose probably a lot of fans if u change too much..

no u cant bc thats the WHOLEEE reason y she became a vampire!!

no u cant bc thats the WHOLEEE reason y she became a vampire!!

[quote=Sara]All fine by me. I just hope to God the filmakers have the sense to cut out Renesme from the story. Just turn her into a vampire and end it there. The forth book with Renesme ruined the whole series for me. I just pretend it was never written[/quote]

1st you spelled renesmee wrong ans 2nd i think she was the greatest part of the story ! your wrong and thats a ; FACT !

I agree with danielle it could seriously mess up Eclipse if they change the marriage condition.

[quote=Sara]All fine by me. I just hope to God the filmakers have the sense to cut out Renesme from the story. Just turn her into a vampire and end it there. The forth book with Renesme ruined the whole series for me. I just pretend it was never written[/quote]

Oh My!! That one was my absolute favorite of all four books. I’m looking forward to that movie more than any others…

NO NO NO NO NOOOOOOOOOO

THEY SHUDNT CHANGE EDWARD’S DEAL WID BELLA…

what about renesmee…

ohhhhhhhhh i love the book… dont spoil the story !!!!

I think its fine to show him when Bella is hearing him…but they better not change anything else cuz it has to b like the book or no one will like it…seriously if they dont get married…will renesmee b in the breaking dawn movie…they better not screw this up!!

[quote=KALINA !]1st you spelled renesmee wrong ans 2nd i think she was the greatest part of the story ! your wrong and thats a ; FACT ![/quote]

ya i agree….renesmee was definitley the best part of the book…and breaking dawn was so the best book!

[quote=LB03]Guarantee you the new ultimatum will be that Edward won’t have sex with hornbag Bella unless they get married. That girl has the hormones of a teenage boy.[/quote]

i would to if my BF looked like that and acted like that:)

[quote=Sara]All fine by me. I just hope to God the filmakers have the sense to cut out Renesme from the story. Just turn her into a vampire and end it there. The forth book with Renesme ruined the whole series for me. I just pretend it was never written[/quote]
f*ck you thats bullsh*t if they cut out renesme they’tes no point to the last book….

sorry – - Renesme*E*

[quote=Sara]All fine by me. I just hope to God the filmakers have the sense to cut out Renesme from the story. Just turn her into a vampire and end it there. The forth book with Renesme ruined the whole series for me. I just pretend it was never written[/quote]Shut your pie hole, the only thing you have to say is irrelevant.