They’re not comic book heroes or sci-fi villains, but the Glee panel to close out this year’s Comic-Con festival was certainly well received. During the discussion, several members of the cast (stars Lea Michele and Matthew Morrison weren’t in the house), one big scoop was revealed: There will be a Rocky Horror Picture Show episode during the second season.

Aside from dropping the dime on the classic campy musical show to come, Glee creator Ryan Murphy was otherwise tight-lipped about shows to come. He did tell the crowd that they’re currently “in negotiation to do a really big tribute episode, but we haven’t closed it yet, so I can’t say.” After the awesomeness of their Lady Gaga and Madonna tributes, here’s hoping they can top themselves.