Kristen Stewart vs. Lily Collins: Who Will Make The Better Snow White?

Kristen Stewart vs. Lily Collins: Snow White?
KStew's Evil Queen?
charlize theron
Will Charlize play opposite Kristen in 'Snow White'? Read More »

Both Kristen Stewart and Lily Collins have been tapped to play Snow White in two separate films but which young starlet will be the fairest of them all? Check out Celebuzz's fairy tale comparison of the two talented actresses after the jump to see which one will be the loveliest Snow White.

Lily Collins

Best Known For: Being Taylor Lautner's girlfriend and Phil Collins' daughter.

Her Handsome Prince: TLuat, duh! The two started dating after they met on the set of their upcoming film, Abduction. However, Lily's on-screen prince will be The Social Network's resident hunk Armie Hammer. Mmm, dreamy.

Her Evil Queen: Lily's on-screen Evil Queen will be none other than Oscar-winner Julia Roberts, who will be breaking her sweetheart image by playing one of the most evil women in fairy tale history.

Why She'll Make a Good Snow White: Lily has the perfect angelic face and her graceful manners will give her Snow White an air of young elegance.

How Lily's Snow White Will Stand Out: The film, which is being produced by action man Brett Ratner, will follow Snow White as she bands together with seven dwarfs to reclaim her kingdom. The film sounds like a big-budget, action-packed film which will stand in sharp contrast from KStew's darker version of the classic fairy tale.

Kristen Stewart

Best Known For: Playing Bella Swan in Twilight.

Her Handsome Prince: While no on-screen Prince has been confirmed for KStew's film, her favorite on-and-off-screen love will forever be Robert Pattinson.

Her Evil Queen: Oscar-winners are turning evil! Charlize Theron has been tapped to star opposite Kristen as the Evil Queen.

Why She'll Make a Good Snow White: Kristen has been acting for years and already has some experience playing an iconic characters (uh, hello – who is more iconic than Bella and Joan Jett?) so she'll be sure to bring something interesting to the table. Plus, Kristen's brand of melancholic cool will give the Brothers Grimm fairy tale a sexy edge.

How Kristen's Snow White Will Stand Out: Stewart's film will be directed by film newbie Rupert Sanders who will be making his directorial debut with this film, so he is sure to give the fairy tale a fresh new angle.

Who do you think will make the better Snow White – Kristen, Lily or both? Vote in our poll and share your thoughts in the comments.
 

Discuss

Default avatar
  • florence
    florence

    you are not her heart or her mind she has the right to make a big role but she only cares the movie's quality. using you brain to think about :why she don't want to be Casey Anthony? well she will make a lot of money, why?? what the hell that you can judge her with that stupid reasons. "she only cares about money." shut up

  • Moon
    Moon

    yeah she's so authentic and all but would you like to be friends with a person like Kristen? If she were your neighbor or if you had gone school with her I bet you wouldn't give a damn about her. She's clearly socially akward due to what I've seen on tv and her interviews she isn't the most polite person in the world.

  • Dan
    Dan

    Both are unattractive. Why they chose two insipid women for the role? If they have ruined it already with Kristen, why they failed casting this Collins girl as Snow White? They could have take advantage of it. I don't get it :/ Monica Keena was a perfect Snow White, beautiful and mysterious. Why they couldn't cast someone who was actually beautiful? And no, inner beauty doesn't count which I doubt Kristen actually has. Maybe the other girl is better than Kristen I haven't seen her work.

  • bluebird
    bluebird

    Yes! Kristen Stewart is perfect Snow White! but Lily Collins... mermaid? Still NO! i saw her in person, she's not the lead role type.

  • metumble
    metumble

    I don't dislike Kristen. But I personally think she can't really act. I mean she can act. But not REALLY. She just does the same thing for each character that she plays. She gets the emotions right most of the time but it's just boring. She doesn't seem to be able to stop that thing with her lips and her eyes and her voice ... it's just always the same!!!

  • wonderstruck
    wonderstruck

    Are you for real? Shut up, you do not know the girl, there for you have NO right whatsoever to judge who she is and what she does.. Oh wow I curse there for I MUST be a bad person.. Get the fuck over yourself you VINDICTIVE CREEP!!! People like you make me sick!!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    And the crazy lying continues! The only person who is damaging Rob is you with your ridiculous obsessional hate of his girlfriend. You may "love" him but I bet you he would hate you if he knew what you were saying about her (maybe he already does).

  • Krizti G
    Krizti G

    I defintly can see Stewart as Snow Withe... not disrespect, Lilly Collins looks like a really cool girl and all... but I just cant see her protraying SW... I mean, Stewart really has the SW look! and I really like this girl, she looks authentic, and she looks like she simple doesnt care what people thinks or talk about her...obivously, she has a really long and good experience, a career... which some may like, or not like, but is a FACT that she has worked hard to be where she is,,,, but is rude to talk BS or bad mouth her... Im pretty sure NONE OF US WRITING HERE REALLY KNOWS HER THAT MUCH! So lets just base or judgment in their FILM experience (I dont care if there is a picture of her smokin something like weed, or if someone says she is swearin all the time, cause WE REALLY DONT KNOW THAT, or just cause she doesnt like going around in Chanel and high hills), and their look alike with the character... Conclusion... I think Kristen Stewart would do a good job as SW... Lilly Collins would be more like a Little Mermaid...

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Stupid Twisted Lies!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Rude and ridiculous lies.

  • sheetal
    sheetal

    dear romantic fool you are very accurate with your views about stutter stewart. It is spot on. However one friend of mine who is not a movie buff happened to just see some interviews of stewart by chance. I asked him to see some stewart movies. He said he can't bear to watch anymore as he has never seen an actor so,so,so BAD ever. He was wondering how she got into movies. He being in the med profession after watching her interviews just mentioned that she looks more like a mentally retarded person.He said that people should not abuse her as she most probably has a genuine medical problem He thinks that the lady should take speech therapy or some treatment as she is totally incoherent while giving interviews. Most of the time she gives random answers not related to the question and looks confused. Her parents should take note. If rob is dating this person then obviously he is not very smart either

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    And more Lies!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Lies!

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    My understanding is that Kristen just was confirmed for playing Snow White but it will be an edgier and "grittier" version. Lilly got the other version. Kristen's costar from On The Road, Viggo Mortensen, suddenly did not want the part of the huntsman. I'm sure it had nothing to do with her personality and charming demeanor. I bet Walt Disney would be speaking up if he was still alive. Perhaps the new Snow White can be called Snow Off White.

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    How odd..You are calling me a fool and ignorant and yet you are the one using bad language, supporting a girl like Kristen that would begrudge giving you an autograph and you don't know.

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    Wow, a true believer. Whatever floats your boat. Don't you get it that she is damaging his image? He is the money maker, she is along for the ride. He more than performed his responsibilities SHE did not and caused very expensive damaging bad publicity. She does not like her fans or appreciate them. She never hardly even mentions them unless she gets another undeserved award from Twi zombies voting for her. Guess what, she lost Kids Choice Awards. She has gays, stoners and goths in her fan base now. Do you identify with that group? Is that why you defend this Hollywood Princess? She could care less about you and has shown her disgust for the fans repeatedly. You are in love with an illusion. She is not shy (she said she was not in Italy) she is not nice and she is not a star. But, hey, keep sticking up for her. She needs all the fans she can get. Soon she will pay people to come to her movies. All of her last movies combined made less than Remember Me which had only an adult audience. The twiheads boycotted it since Rob was making out with Emilie in the movie. She may have been nice during Speak and Cake Eaters. She is not now. Fights and yelling matches on set from her with costars is well known. Visit some other sites for another view.

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    I have said positive things about her when it is true. She has tried to clean up her mouth lately on camera. She looks less haggard as she realized her looks were being affected by her lifestyle and habits. At Eclipse premier she was asked for advice for the young fans and she said "be healthy and fxxx everyone" but she did look nice in the white dress and her hair up. Her eyes were less blood shot and shadowed. When she gave the finger repeatedly, it was manicured thanks to the money she made off of a movie supported by young fans. When the video of her kissing Nikki in the car got put online, she was at least not toking in it. When she told the fans that they were "fxxxing retards, she did sign a few autographs first. When she blabbed about Rob's personal business, she did not do it on national tv. When she tweeted the location they were at so the paps could give her some much needed publicity, she tipped the waitress first.

  • wonderstruck
    wonderstruck

    Ignoring all the HATERS!! Because lets face it, who the fuck cares what they think.. Muhh.. Ignorant fools.. Apart from the Twilight Saga my fave KStew films are The Cake Eaters and the small role she had in Into The Wild.. Brilliance.. Cannot wait to see her in Snow White and On The Road.. :)

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    You're just crazy. Rob is in love with Kristen and has been for a long time (which lets face it is the real reason you hate her!) All of your twisted research, contrived stories and downright lies are not going to break them up! All of this robs a little angel, and kristens not worthy of him crap makes me laugh! Rob knows her intimately and she knows him intimately and they obviously know each other better than you could ever know them! But good luck with your pointless stories. They will never achieve anything!

  • Kamm
    Kamm

    To romantic fool, it is not hateful 'to discuss what she has said and done', but u seem to see only one side of the coin, that is the bad side & convinced what u think is gospel truth. this is not healthy criticism. that is why KS fans here are upset and rightly so. think hard, u also may not be totally perfect urself...nobody is. try not to see and highlight only negative things in other ppl. it will do nobody any good.

  • Kamm
    Kamm

    after watching her in 'Speak', I am confident KS can pull up any role. also if she is really cast as a snow white, I am sure that the concerned studio had a good reason to cast her and they didn't do it out of charity! am not acquainted with the other girl's acting ability, so can't comment. But best of luck to both, look forward to watch both versions.

  • Kamm
    Kamm

    wow, ok, from now on, before i watch a movie or read a book, i will try to research on the actors, directors and the writers to see what is their 'REAL' (?) persona, find out everything i can (will hire a detective agency if needed). only if they happen to be 'talented, articulate, kind, charitable, confident and classy' and am confident they r totally goody 2 shoes, never swear in public, never try to corrupt 'impressionable' minds, will i honor them by watching/reading them. really, u have made me a convert!!!

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    Thanks for your insightful post. The reason that she acted badly during the New Moon break up scene was because in reality, she had been gently rejected by Rob. The first day of filming (on dvd) she was radiant and happy looking. She thought she was going to pick up with Rob from where they left off on Twi set. In Entertainment Weekly August magazine she said during the scene she had to keep going to her car and "fxxxing sobbing and stuff during the break up scene and was so intimidated by it". That sorrow sure did not conveyed. She was wooden as usual. She was very hostile towards him (shows during the out takes when Rob gives his Romeo & Juliet speech in class). It showed in Italy too. She was shattered and vacant looking. From that point on, she changed. There was very damaging scandal that was covered up by Summit as well. Her acting was bad in Twilight but Rob pulled it off and created Edward with little besides a description and perfect as the character. Because Rob is a caring, sensitive and Christian guy, he treated her well and with kindness. She thought it was because he wanted to date her. He said "she is very intimidating, fierce, angry and shocking". When he started dating other people (Kristen supposedly was with Michael Angararo-friend of Twi director), Kristen's looks, behavior, mouth and acting went downhill. They salvaged their friendship and have an understanding now. He kept her secret and was a loyal friend. Kristen shot her mouth off, got sloppy and the cat is out of the bag now. Her reputation is shot in LA for her conduct and personal habits. She did it to herself.

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    It is not hateful to discuss what she has said and done. We live in a free society that has free speech for the time being anyways. Debate is healthy but the left always resorts to name calling and bad language. It is like they are from a different planet and the rules that govern the rest of us don't apply to them. Since when is it okay to use curses and sex talk on a site visited by the general public??? ONLY the left and uneducated people conduct themselves this way. This girl would not be as far as she is if her fans knew the truth about her awful behavior and more of us parents had spoken up sooner. Our society is in the dumps partly due to bad behavior getting as pass. A star does drugs and gets sympathy and rehab. When a guy like Rush Limbaugh gets hooked on pain killers for his extreme back pain, there is NO sympathy and only ridicule. HYPOCRITES. The non-Christian, left are the most hypocritical, double standard implementing, cruelest, crudest and rudest people on the net. The language, dirty remarks, sex talk, sexing up of our kids, making women sex objects etc. always leads back to the liberal progressives running the media and net. They ruined our society and kids. The gays ruined the reputation of the Church NOT the straight priests. A civil society must push back against their influences or we continue to lose our culture, moral foundation and spiral downward. The FCC, Cyber Cop, FBI and other watch groups have got to do their job or lose their funding. Kristen was more mature, more groomed, more articulate 3 years ago. She is a train wreck. I think this site if for expressing opinion. Hopefully, young people here stop and think..If bad behavior and inappropriate conduct is discussed and not glorified or admired as is the usual case on these sites, maybe some impressionable girl without guidance in her life will stay on track and not wreck their lives.Maybe someone struggling with their faith and/or morals will see that going along with the crowd is not a good choice. People like Taylor Swift, Camilla Belle, Leighton Meester and Selena Gomez are talented, articulate, kind, charitable, confident and classy. They are fashionable, attractive and know how to conduct themselves. Kristen Stewart's parents should be ashamed of themselves for raising a girl that says "mofo and the f word" in every other sentence in national publications. Kristen can't put a sentence together and represent the movie and the director which is her job. Watch her at Sundance Film Fest in the press conferences. THAT IS THE REAL KRISTEN. Her fans need to get a clue.

  • wall
    wall

    Love Kristen. I am looking forward to seeing how her career expands and develops. She is only 20 years old yet some idiots have her written off. She is loved by a lot of people and in the industry has a lot of professionals who sing her praises and want to work with her. I think Snow White is an interesting choice for her and brave too considering the backlash but I for one can not wait to see it.

  • sheetal
    sheetal

    Casting Kristen Stewart in any movie is an insult to many young and talented young girls. Reason she is here is only because of her parents influence. There are many people who are really talented and cannot make it because they do not have the contacts. Reason I am writing this is because i finally read the twilight saga books, which was with me for the past 2 years. I sort of liked it even though the books have some flaws. Then i decided to see the movies on DVD's. The first one is just OK though the director could have made it better by adding few more scenes. Kristen’s acting looked dull but people didn't notice it because of Rob. Focus naturally went from Kristen to Rob and she was just in the background. But the director somehow managed to retain the chemistry between the two. Yesterday saw New Moon. I cant say how disappointed I am. What should I say? Bad direction and bad screenplay adding unnecessary scenes in Voltura, which portrays Rob as a weakling. What about Kristen? Is she an actress or what? She just stood there as if she was reading the script. No emotions what so ever. The part where Rob is leaving her it seemed to me that she was bored and was waiting for him to go. Rob still had some emotions on his face. Kristen should have acted hysterical or in shock. Months that passed were shown her sitting on a chair without shedding a tear. When she meets Jacob she is very active. She didn't come across as somebody who is grieving. Between rob and Kristen was there any chemistry? I think the director didn't even read the book. He was just there relying on the horrible script and horrible actress to do the job. It is inexcusable of Kristen to give such a poor performance as she is in this field for the past 8 years. Rob and Taylor have improved drastically although they are not born actors like Leonardo Di Caprio. I am sure with time they will also be good. I was wondering is there any way this movie could be remade with a different Bella or are we stuck with this emotionless statue forever. Her poor acting is in fact detrimental for her fellow actors. Just because the rumor that Pattinson is dating her is circulating she has some supporters. People want to see them together. Once when twilight saga is finished she will be finished. Saw Eclipse. Had to switch off because Kristen’s acting was horrible as ever. Rob was horrible too. Maybe he does not get the right motivation to act when a wooden statue is in front of him. She lacks depth in her acting. Welcome to the Riley’s is the best she can do. That is a straightforward role with wooden miserable expressions. To act well the actor should know the character they play well. Unfortunately she doesn't know her characters well. That’s why for every role there is stuttering, lip biting, inhaling exhaling loudly and blinking. That's her trademark acting. No other emotion is possible. Can she shed few tears at the appropriate time? Never. When people say that is her twihard fans that she is worthy of Oscars I feel like puking. What an insult to Alpacino, Robert De Niro and Marlon Brando. They should watch the speech of Alpacino in the Scent of a Woman. If she can produce even a micro ounce of that acting she can go a long way.

  • i know who
    i know who

    KRISTEN STEWART, FOR SURE!! SHE IS WAY BETTER!! Haters gonna hate .|.

  • ali
    ali

    Lily Collins of corus

  • Tyler
    Tyler

    Anyone is better than Stewart

  • Steff17
    Steff17

    Kristen is the best!!! I mean the movies will be very different!!, I prefer kristen!!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Yes, it is a bit like talking to a wall. I find it completely bizarre but somewhat fascinating. Of course its easy to paint anybody in the light someone wants to. Its so easy but certain people think they have the 411!! It kind of amuses me to be honest!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Oh dear God. Your real 411 is only your 411. Its not the truth. My thoughts on Rob is that he is a decent, intelligent and caring young man. It is not wrong or unfair to safely assume he is with Kristen, who is also decent, intelligent and caring. He is smart enough to know how he feels about someone he has known for years and they are obviously close. I wish them lots of love and happiness. They obviously feel safe together and weather the crazy storms together!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Oh dear God. Your real 411 is only your 411. Its not the truth. My thoughts on Rob is that he is a decent, intelligent and caring young man. It is not wrong or unfair to safely assume he is with Kristen, who is also decent, intelligent and caring. He is smart enough to know how he feels about someone he has known for years and they are obviously close. I wish them lots of love and happiness. They obviously feel safe together and weather the crazy storms together!

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    I don't hate her. I am simply sharing what she does and pointing out why she is not worthy of her fame, admiration and fortune brought on by her knowing Rob and the Twi series. She is full of hatred towards the fans and towards normal behavior. I just report her behavior and the real 411 since so many think she is sweet, talented and with Rob. As far as Rob's being open and sharing his VERY MAINSTREAM BELIEFS being made fun of here, shame on all of you vapid, jaded, unromantic crude and nasty people! Young people pay attention to what stars say and especially what he says. Please stop sending me hate mail at the igossip site, If Rob had said on video that he is jumping on 3 girls every night, you'd believe that. the problem is that people like Ted of Awful Truth has spreading his twisted opinion for so long that everyone assumes. I don't assume. Why not believe what the guy said in 2008? Perhaps that has changed recently, but for people to assume otherwise is just wrong and unfair to him. Read In Style Italy. Watch the interviews.

  • Kamm
    Kamm

    Hey ymwm, i dont understand why u r wasting time replying these ppl who r surely mental to actually do time-consuming researches to prove a teenage actor to be an evil person in order 2 justify their unreasonable hatred 4 her!!! they also find out KS's pics and articles so that they can place these hate comments. :) Amazing isn't it? I guess it must have a clinical name, other than simply 'hatred'. BTW, i like KS as an actor, but am no fan and I certainly don't think she has done anything to warrant this kind of hatred from a complete stranger. poor girl!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Wrong!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Jelena. Its really just a little clique of haters who have developed fake and odd reasons to hate her. Weird I know! Anyone who hates someone they dont know, especially for false or contrived reasons is not the full shilling in my opinion!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Well arent you just charming? I really hoped people like you didnt exist in the World. Rude words, hateful message, ignorant comment and aggressive tone! Its a pity you're not famous because then everyone could hate you for the very reasons they hate kristen. The only difference is in your case the reasons would be very seemingly true!

  • PEOPLE IN SHOCK
    PEOPLE IN SHOCK

    Kirsten Stewart cant act fucking Rob isnt acting she sucks her fans/lesbianwhors need accept it

  • jelena
    jelena

    WOW I didnt know Kristen was sooo hated

  • jelena
    jelena

    WOW I didnt know Kristen was sooo hated

  • Back cops
    Back cops

    Kristen Stewart is the worst actress in history just accept it. she suck, she ugly, she is a milf, and a fucking pot smoker. She sells sex to children most of her fans are lesbian. Chicks that cant get a dude likes her. Fuck all her fans and her. U CAN TAKE YOUR SEAT TO HELL. The other chick is much better than her anyone is better than that shit

  • edwardbella2
    edwardbella2

    i am sorry but i guess you have got a lot of free time that you write such big comments.

  • bones
    bones

    Go Kristen <333 !!!

  • huitou88
    huitou88

    Wonderful. Share a website with you , http:// ( www ) . ( goodshopping ) . ( us ) Believe you will love it. We accept any form of payment

  • edwardbella2
    edwardbella2

    KRISTEN is going to rock as snow white.and i guess if she can play bella well than she can do snow white up to the mark as well.and plz guys and gals stop fighting every one has got their own opinion.

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    You know what goes around comes around right? I wish you luck in life..with your karma..you're really going to need it!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Thats just disgusting and inhuman! And you think Kristen is vulgar? Please! From what you just said the only vulgar one is you and that is putting it very mildly!!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Who do you think you are? You have just displayed ignorance and fabrication. How do you know all she cares about is money? Oh yeah...you dont! Lies...and ugly lies at that!

  • AC/DC
    AC/DC

    Get a live lesbianwhor she smoks weed all day she dont care if u think shes perfect. She only care about the mony that all

  • Gaga for live
    Gaga for live

    I hope drugs kills kristen fuckings stewart soon

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Juno. There really is no need to be confused. Pretty much everything she said was completely made up or twisted in a negative light by someone who hates her! I could show you lots of examples of Kristen being sweet and caring if I had the time or inclination. I find it strange that someone can hate someone they dont know so much! I respect that you dont do that.

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Kitty really? She makes money thats why she got the role? I thought nobody likes her and her support is dwindling? So which is it?? Oh yeah...its neither! A whole lot of famous people make a lot of money for movies...is that the reason they all get roles, (or just Kristen)? Like I said top critics who actually know what they are talking about give her lots of praise. I'd rather go by their opinion than yours.

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Your reasons for hating her are repulsive, superficial and false. It doesnt matter what anyone says you will continue to hate her because you want to hate her. I will continue to respect her and wish her the best in life because she has to put up with people maliciously fabricating stories about her. I would think as a Rob fan you would a least respect his judgement and give him credit for being an intelligent person who is capable of deciding what people he wants to spend his time with. If she is the type of person he likes to spend his time with then she must be all the things people who know her (including Rob) describe her as. Smart, talented, sweet, caring and professional. Like I said I'm sure you'll just keep on hating her because you've got this contrived "devil woman" imagine of her in you head. You just hate everything about her...but I think that says more about you, than her really.

  • juno
    juno

    omg you make her look like the most horrible person in the world not just actress, i dont know if what you said is true but am really freaked out by it, i cant judge anyone without knowing him and i dont rely on magazines to know the truth about someone.she seems like a strong and independent and i like seeing that in a girl. i really like her but am confused right now

  • Kitty
    Kitty

    I agree! No range!

  • Kitty
    Kitty

    Kristen Stewart makes money. Its not about whether she has talent at all...which she does not. Just face it.

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    If she is hated, it is because she pissed off so many people. I don't like her and find her repulsive. Your reasons for supporting her are flimsy.

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    OMG! She was the worst swearer out of a bunch of swearers! How awful! (that was sarcasm by the way) I'm informed!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Top critics see her as a quality actress. Thats all I need to say about her talent! No she is not Snow White and guess what, Christian Bale is not Batman! I'm actually not a krisbian or whatever but I do respect her for being different and true to herself .She wont change because some people hate her. She has put up with a lot of crazy bull! She's a strong minded girl. Sounds like a good role model to me!

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    He said she has the worst. Read the article, get informed and you'll stop worshiping this punk.

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    i AM SAYING . that since she can't act and most people know the real situation with her, they won't buy her playing a beloved Disney character. Like she said to Entertainment Weekly Magazine in August 2009, "I'm so not Bella" she is so not Snow White. i speak up because sane parents don't want more teens looking up to this ungrateful, untalented, unprofessional dope. You must be another Krisbian with a crush that thinks she is a great role model. . . .

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    BTW I adore Rob but half the time in interviews he is just kidding around, as is Kristen! Maybe you just dont get their humor but its one thing they have in common because they certainly seem to enjoy each others company and make each other laugh!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    I wonder do you just decide the way something "is" about other peoples lives and contrive stories to suit your concoctions. Quite frankly what you've just said is completely libel and a lot of it is just plain ridiculous. You dont know anything about their relationship, who they are as people or what his family thinks of her. You just made it up to suit your own agenda! Its a bit odd and unnecessary in my opinion but I doubt that will have any impact on you..but I suppose your opinion wont have any impact on Rob or Kristen either so whats the bloody point?

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    I forgot to mention the tape of her announcing that Rob had little experience with girls and mocking him. You see, he dated the same girl next door (Nina Schubert) for 3-4 years. Then he was abroad filming Little Ashes in Spain and How To Be in the UK. He came to the states for Twi at 21, shy and a late bloomer. He is a practicing Catholic. He stated that he was celibate and waiting for the right girl in 2008. She blabbed to everyone. Type in http:// youtu.be/A9pFZ8xnrT4 <2:35 point or so Never has there been such a mismatched screen couple. He has morals, is old fashioned and nice. She is the opposite. Rob gave an interview talking about his beliefs, values and not being into meaningless sex without feeling recently in Italy’s Style Magazine. Look for it on Hollywoodlife.com The guy is such a sweetheart and she is a fraud.

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    Who else leaked his pic of her with his mom and dad and him in England in his parents living room? It was not his family (they can't stand her). She also released the ones after the Remember Me after party that she crashed uninvited. She was told to attend (he never goes to her stuff and never brings her when not in the line of duty) to help promote buzz for her movie which was also a Summit project. He was wasted in the pics as was his agent and Tom. Who else would leak it? She does it for publicity as nobody wants anything to do with her or bothers her if she is not with Rob. They have a working relationship and know each other well. They are friends. I don't know her but enough of her cast mates have commented on her to make me convinced I don't want to know her. Billy Burke (her dad in Twi) said she is scary and he is afraid of her. The wolf pack said she was tough, Rob said she was intimidating, shocking, angry and fierce in 2008 in an interview. Kellan Lutz talked about her being a yeller. Chris Weitz said she had the filthiest mouth of the entire cast, crew and sailor out there. Rachelle Le Fevre said she was always fighting with Rob and bossing him. Weitz and Slade said they had never worked with such a difficult actor. Slade recounted his statement about them being together as being misquoted. Perez Hilton said she is gay and others. gaygirl2000.blogspot.com/2009/06/is-kristen-stewart-gay.html There is plenty more. Perhaps you should visit other sites that are not on the payroll for Summit to get the real 411. There is much worse stuff but I don't want to blow you mind. If a 20 year old guy had eluded to an intimate/sexual relationship with a 15 year old girl like Kristen did repeatedly in interviews (see Sundance Film Fest before they take the rest down) or You Tube "Kristen Stewart kissing Dakota was cool", they would have been questioned and/or arrested. Nobody is buying it was a joke but Kristen's die hard fans. She needs to apologize for her horrible behavior in the line of work. She is in breach of contract for causing bad pr at least. Then she can crawl back under the rock she came out from and go to charm school.

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Firstly you do not know if she is bisexual and even if she was it would not interfere with her work in any way. To say that she has a tude and walk like a man is frankly ridiculous and not relevant as you said she can act feminine. So she cant play a sweet virginal maiden because she is not one, is that what you're saying? She is also not a stripper but she could act that. She hasnt ever played the boring sweet girl but that doesnt mean she cant. Also her snow white movie does not require her to be just sweet and virginal!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    You're really just grasping at straws now. So Chris Weitz said she swears a lot as does pretty much everybody else in the cast. Quote "Those kids have some mouths". Nobody who knows her said she was vulgar, BOSSY or difficult.Then you show me some comments by random people on celebuzz and you say I should not believe Ted (which i dont) but you can use and believe Hollywoodlife and celebuzz! Come on!!

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    How does a bisexual girl with a mouth like a sewer, leads a wild like as per her own words, has a walk and 'tude like a man when not acting feminine, play a sweet virginal maiden? She can't act so she can't pull it off. She plays stripper and lesbian well. Many of the videos have been removed that showed her at Sundance Film Fest as her true self. SHE IS SHOCKING. Here are a few to get you started.Put www and youtube.com/watch?v=sYiUFJ0XK-8

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    look what celebuzz said about her ---type in www .celebuzz.com/photos/which-female-celeb-should-kristen-stewart-hook-up-with/

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    That is what you have been told by spinners on the payroll like Ted of Awful Truth. As soon as the directors were no longer under contract, they said she was vulgar, BOSSY and difficult. see www hollywoodlife.com/2010/03/22/kristen-stewart-dirty-mouth/

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    What are you talking about? You have way too much interest in someone you claim to have no interest in! No matter how much "homework" you do on her, you dont actually know her, yet you say you see her for who she really is? Please. I'd take the word of people who actually do know her over your "homework" any day and they say she is caring, sweet, professional and smart. As for sharing private info and pics of Robs? (who seems to really care about her and vice versa) Why in Gods Earth would she do that? I literally can not wait for your answer!

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    You must not have seen her interviews, read them, watched her in the line of work and know the real 411 on this twit. You like an illusion. I see her for what she is. Troubled. Never has there been such a crude, combative, hostile and nasty "star". She can barely manage to pretend at the premieres and press junkets. There are hundreds of girls awho would love to be in her shoes with more talent, more gratitude and don't make repeatedly bad publicity. Whether making out with girls, giving the finger, smoking a bong, sharing private info and photos of Rob's, calling the fans retards, refusing to sign autographs, using obscene and foul language in print and video interviews, or telling the teen fans to "be healthy and fxxx everyone" this girl is the ultimate unprofessional. Her fan base is dwindling because people have actually done their own homework and not been blind Krisbian sheep like you.

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    All you have done is waste your time looking for pictures of Kristen to illustrate her the way you want to. I could do this for ANYBODY if I so desired. In fact I could just post loads of pics of her smiling now to show another side to her but whats the point? You'll see her the way you want to. But there are 402,000 on google images.

  • romanticfool
    romanticfool

    Kristen is good at playing lesbian rockers like Joan Jett and messed up strippers like Mallory in Welcome To The Rileys. She can relate to those roles. She is not convincing as Bella or as a sweet and pure Snow White. If you think this girl can act, then you must think staring, biting lips, looking beat and speaking in a monotone voice is acting. This girl is not who you think she is. Read her print interviews and watch on You Tube "Kristen Stewart: Happy Moments Part 1" She is the most unprofessional and over-rated young actor in H-wood. Her former directors said she was difficult, bossy, foul mouthed and unpredictable. She would be fired if she behaved the way she has in the real world at work.

  • Guest
    Guest

    KRISTEN hands down. This young actress has been very good in her movies that I have seen. Her movie is the more edgier one just like Kristen. She is the best choice for this movie. Sorry but lilly classy??? those eyebrows can't get over them like caterpillars sorry this girl does nothing for me. Nothing against her but holly cow please get them thinned.

  • S.OCD
    S.OCD

    Kristeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeennnn ALL the EFFINg way!!!!!

  • juno
    juno

    of course kristen will do better because she's been acting since she was 12 so she has the experience also she's a tough girl she can handle this dark role, on the other hand we haven't seen lily acting before but she might surprise us and do a good job though the winner will be definitely kristen

  • Anna
    Anna

    I think Lily will be better. She has the more classical beauty look. Kristen might work for a darker take but she has no range. She plays all her characters the same.

  • Missy B
    Missy B

    Both would be good in each part. They're two totally different movies - from the same story. And they're both great actresses, I'm looking forward to both movies.

  • Noly
    Noly

    100% agree!

  • Nina
    Nina

    Lily Collins \o\

  • bike
    bike

    kristen stewart hands down why is even up for debate.

  • Lelli
    Lelli

    kristen stewart. no contest. and i'm not a die-hard twilight fan. i just think she'll play the role better.

  • JANELLE
    JANELLE

    KRISTEN STEWART IS PERFECT FOR THE ROLE!! SHE HAS AN AMAZING MYSTERIOUS ATTITUDE AND AN ICY LOOK THAT WOULD GO PERFECT WITH THE CREEPIER VERSION OF THE STORY. SHE ALSO HAS THE PERFECT SKIN TONE!!

  • ymwm
    ymwm

    Kristen Stewarts version is much more appealing to me. It has action and intrigue and generally seems more exciting. Although I'd say Lilys version will do well too and suit a lot of people who like the sweeter take on the original grimm tale. Just to note for the negative nancys out there Kristen Stewart has impressed top critics with her performances and she is regarded by industry professionals as a great actress. I would value their opinion on the subject.

  • lalaa
    lalaa

    LIP BITING,STUTTERING,HAIR FLIPPING ,UNCONTROLABLE BLINKING and INHALE/EXHALE LOUDLY AS ACTING GO AHEAD.She a shame for actress and Hollywood. Her fans are stupid and blind Lilly Collins is much bettter

  • EMinem 4 ever
    EMinem 4 ever

    Anyone but Kristen fuckings Stewart

  • rea
    rea

    Kristen Stewart. No contest.

  • sophie1986
    sophie1986

    I can’t wait to see how Kristen Stewart decides to play the scene in which she eats the poisened apple and falls into a deep coma. Ten bucks says she plays it like really bad heartburn. She’s such a subtly sensitive actress.

  • jennyjazz
    jennyjazz

    If I had to choose between the two of them I would rather see Lilly Collins in the role.

 
celebuzz

Top Stories

Get the Scoop

Sign up for the daily Celebuzz Newsletter and stay in the know.