Spoiler alert: ‘American Idol’ Sends First Guy Home

Idol Finalists!
Learn more about the AI final 13.
If you missed this week’s American Idol elimination, Celebuzz has your cheat sheet to find out who got the boot! Tonight, the very first male contestant was eliminated.

After last night’s performances, it wasn’t too surprising to see that Stefano Langone and Paul McDonald were the bottom two guys left awaiting their fate. Guess who went home?

Goodbye Paul! His quirky dance moves, wild suits and bright white smile couldn’t save the folk rock singer and he was sent packing.

“Let’s not make this sad,” he said, as Jennifer Lopez requested he sing “Maggie May” one final time. Many fans felt he had the unique sensibilities that make a star. Could he be the next Jennifer Hudson or Chris Daughtry?  Only time will tell. For now, only six more contestants remain before the new American Idol is crowned!