Report: Justin Bieber’s Alleged Baby Mama Mariah Yeater Made Paternity Claim Against Ex

Mariah Yeater made headlines earlier this week when she claimed that Justin Bieber was the father of her baby, but according to TMZ, this isn’t the first guy she has made a paternity claim against.

TMZ is claiming that Mariah insisted that her ex-boyfriend John Terranova was the father of her child in December 2010, and the two got into an altercation after she showed up at his home to make the claims.

According to John’s grandmother, Frances Lippe:

“The two got into an argument and police were called because Yeater allegedly broke a car window out of rage. Later that day, according to the police report, Yeater returned to the home to work out a payment plan for the window and got into another altercation with Terranova and allegedly slapped John 3 separate times in the face with her open right hand. Yeater was arrested and charged for battery. A court date has been set in Vegas. Lippe tells us after the altercation, they never heard from Yeater again.”

Mariah claims that she and JB hooked up after one of his show’s at the Staples Center in LA last summer, and that Justin is the father of her 3-month-child.

The Biebs called the lawsuit “sad,” telling

“It’s sad that someone would fabricate malicious, defamatory and demonstrably false claims. We will vigorously pursue all available legal remedies to defend and protect Justin against these allegations.”

What do you think of this situation? Sound off in the comments!