Rachel Crow Eliminated From ‘The X Factor’: Did She Deserve to Be Sent Home? (POLL)

By: / December 9, 2011

Given how many shocking eliminations we saw on American Idol, it was only a matter of time before one happened on The X Factor.

Such was the case on last night’s elimination show, in which America bid adieu to 13-year-old singer Rachel Crow.

Rachel was understandably shocked and upset after the results were red, and immediately dropped to the floor, where she began to sob uncontrollably.

The results have since reflected poorly on judge Nicole Scherzinger, who opted not to cast her judges’ vote and instead let America make the decision. LA Reid voted to keep Marcus Canty, while Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul chose to keep Rachel.

Given how talented Rachel was on the show, we’re not sure she deserved to go home last night. Did the show make the right decision? Or should Marcus have gotten the boot? Vote now in our poll!