Will Evan Peters (Tate) Return to 'American Horror Story'? Creator Ryan Murphy Drops Clues to Season Two

After last nights American Horror Story finale, fans are wondering if Evan Peters (seen here in a scary hot Tyler Shields shoot) will return? Creator Ryan Murphy gave a few hints about the returning cast for season two! 

WARNING! Spoilers ahead (but no ghosts)!

"Some of [the cast] will be coming back," he told MSNBC. "There will be familiar faces and also some new faces," Murphy teased. "The people that are coming back will be playing completely different characters, creatures, monsters, etc. [The Harmons'] stories are done. People who are coming back will be playing entirely new characters." Unfortunately, he stayed completely mum on which actors might be coming back. "I would have them all back in a heartbeat. I think we'll announce the full cast and what the new storyline is going to be some time in February."

The scenery will be changing too, he says, "What you saw in the finale was the end of the Harmon house. The second season of the show will be a brand-new home or building to haunt. Just like this year, every season of this show will have a beginning, middle and end. [The second season] won't be in L.A. It will obviously be in America, but in a completely different locale."

For more season two spoilers, he hinted, "There is a clue in the last three episodes where we resay what the next season will be about."



Default avatar
  • Jenna

    i still want to know what happened with violet and tate, and it's killing me knowing that i'll NEVER know because they're changing the whole plot line ! ugh !

  • jdasfkn

    NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO....tate is the best character ever....CONTINUE THE STORY.

  • ggggggggggiiirrrlll

    The show is great guys, but the end of the finale was totally shocking. We all love Tate, but what about his kid??

  • candice1983

    People: when the series first came out he said that it would be a new family/house in each season....and Tate & Violets relationship is over, she said goodbye to him and her dad told him that Violet can never forgive Tate soooo hence relationship over....all that will happen now in the harmon house is the harmons will scare away families and tate/hayden will ALWAYs be watching waiting....not much more can be told about the house....I definitely will miss the characters but its a horror story not romance...I am EXCITED to see where the new season will be and go!!! This is one of the best shows ever on tv!

  • camila

    estoy totalmente enamorada e evan peters y no quiero que se valla de esa serie es por la unica razon que la miro!

  • joey

    That whole idea can't even be a possibility. The new season is about a new story completely. The Harmon's are over, that house in LA is over. Ryan Murphy said it could be about anything from serial killers, to witches, anything except for vampires. So this new season might feature some of your favorite actors from season 1, but unfortunately they will not hold the same name, or the same character as they did in season 1.

  • IsleOfMan

    I found out about american horror story last night, because I'm from a small island in the middle of ireland and england. But as soon as I watched the first one I became obsessed and have watched every episode, and fell in love with tate straight away. the second series better be good man comon.

  • Andrea

    THE LEAST HE CAN DO IS MAKE EPISODE ONE OF SEASON TWO A FOLLOW UP OF SEASON ONE'S FINALE, SHOWING TATE AND VIOLET FINALLY TOGETHER... that's all the happy ending i need...then he can move on to whatever he's planning to show in Florida, idgaf. As long as Evan's still there. And most of the other amazing cast, as well, but mostly Evan. - @anDREAMdookhie.

  • Anna Elizabeth Stewart
    Anna Elizabeth Stewart

    I totally don't like the idea. I think they could have definitely went a lot farther with the story lines they already had going with everyone from the original house. They could have dragged out many different things about season 1. Evan Peters makes the show what it is. Each character has their own little reasoning for what they do, but Evan definitely was my favorite from the get go. If they decide to switch everything up & remove Evan Peters from the cast, I won't be watching. Tate is hellish and beautiful and brings so much to the show its unbelievable. I wonder how many others feel this way? I've talked to a few people about it and they think the idea is brilliant. I became connected to this cast, and I don't see how its going to make the storyline any better or help the show in any way. Did they switch the cast up and replace everyone each season on Lost? No, that show did amazing, and I'm sure had the casting been switched around it wouldn't have done nearly as well. This goes for any other decent, well written television series. The characters make the show. Always.

  • C

    I don't like how Tate and Violets relationship was left hanging up in the air..TEAM VIOLATE all the way! Please bring back Evan and Tarissa!

  • evanpetersishot

    Allie this isn't a soap opera or a family comedy series..It's a horror show (American Horror Story).Guys if he has decided to get an entire new cast and location then that's his decision and they are probably already in production of it...But HE will know how wrong HE is after HE sees the ratings without the harmons and beautiful Evan Peters <3

  • Heather Gibson
    Heather Gibson

    Really?!?!?!?! Why would you change something so great? I mean he probably came into making this show with the entire idea of changing the cast and location with each season but I doubt they expected it to be this successful... I probably won't watch if Evan Peters isn't in the new season...I dig the stories and I'm a horror junkie but let's be honest...Most of us just watch it because of how gorgeous he is..am I right? Yes.

  • Allie

    This is the best show..I haven't watched a series in a long time because there hasn't been one worth watching..Who ever the casting agent is BRAVO!! You couldn't have done a bettter job.The chemistry with Evan and Jessica is remarkable! You have to bring them back..Since the new season is about change then make it to where they are finally able to get Tate out of the house somehow and they have to constantly move because of the things little Michael (Tate's son) does.Make it where Tate is trying to become a good person and Constance is actually trying to be a good mother for once...No matter where little Michael goes he will see ghost considering he is part ghost himself! So, there will always be some type of spooky stuff going on.I don't know how many people caught this but the child actual sees things the way the ghost do not the way the humans do!! MUST BRING BACK TATE AND CONSTANCE!!

  • Hayley

    im not watching it if tate is not on it -.-

  • Meriadoc Brandybuck
    Meriadoc Brandybuck

    Dear Ryan Murphy, Please bring back Tate and Violet. Honestly, the way you left that relationship hanging in the air was NOT COOL. I want to see them getting back together or both of them finding someone else or something I don't know. I just really want those two characters back; they were great. And why not admit it, I want Tate back also because is really hot.

  • margaret

    Maybe they will use Evan as an "adult" Michael?

  • Bee

    That's really disturbing.

  • jana

    noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo i like The Harmons the should keep the house and led another family move in

  • Destiny

    I think that it's a good idea to change the cast. If it's his vision then I don't see a problem with it. I trust it. And, as he is the creator of Glee, we know he has problems with continuity anyway, so this will be a great way to not have to deal with that. As far as Evan Peters goes... he is an AMAZING actor and I think they need to keep him on. They'd be crazy not to. I also think they should keep on Alexandra Breckenridge, if not simply for her amazing talent, just look at her she is gorgeous!!! Frances Conroy as well, she's also another amazing talent. I also wouldn't mind seeing more of Lily Rabe. There was so much talent in this show.

  • Chloe

    This is a complete load of crap! No one is going to watch this show if he screws it all up. No one will like it and I hope that this idiot reads this, because I'm personally angry at him. Don't blow your shot at a great series you fool!

  • Mary

    If Evan Peters returns and is part of the main cast, then I will give the new season a shot. However, I feel that this whole business is very disorganized. IMDB also said that Tate was only going to be in 7 episodes when the show first began and that Adelaide was going to be there for the entire season. Obviously this isn't how it happened. I was expecting him to leave in episode 7, but instead Adelaide dies. So, who knows what's going to happen.

  • A

    The new season will probably be in Florida! They mentioned that a bajillion times!

  • d

    I hope the creators read this. Baby Michael cant come back as someone else or be just gone....Constance is returning from what Ive read but these characters will be other people. Maybe this was a one season show...Evan Peters is remarkable. What a shame...they might just blow it.

  • tricia treason
    tricia treason

    if this comes true i will be pissed off!!!!!!i have been there since the first wednesday..i havent missed an episode..i literally missed my aunts funeral to watch this show..if you take tate away from me i will have a mental break..this show makes me sane...heres a hint: keep the cast!!!

  • Juliana

    im not watching it if tate is not on it -.-

  • victoria

    He better make a second season. I know it will be as good as the first. I couldn't wait to watch the next episode. It had me on my toes every second of the whole episodes. MAKE MORE SEASONS!!!!

  • Bex (brazilian)
    Bex (brazilian)

    Actually, I just want two of the cast from first season, of course, Tate and Violet, I wanna know about what will happen between them after all, because for me isn't ended. I'll be really sad, and I don't know if I'll watch the show, if Tate and Violet don't come back...both. Mainly Tate (Evan Peters), I really like this guy.

  • ashley

    this is bull i don't want the Harmon,s to be over with i still want to know more about them. i dont know how i feel about it yet.

  • jillk

    I agree 'Fan of the show'.

  • Fan of the show
    Fan of the show

    I was talking about Evan Peters.

  • Fan of the show
    Fan of the show

    He'd better. He's the best actor I've seen since Michael C. Hall. He makes the show-if he's not back don't know if I will watch the show.