Readers Respond: Who Should Play Carrie Bradshaw in ‘Sex and the City’ TV prequel?

SJP Talks 'SATC 3'
Sarah Jessica Parker in Parade
Sarah Jessica Parker talks about third 'SATC' movie. Read More »

After it was announced Wednesday that The CW network had picked up a Sex and The City prequel, we here at Celebuzz got to thinking about who should play the renowned Miss Carrie Bradshaw (the younger edition).

We asked you, the readers, to help us out with which young Hollywood starlet has got the acting chops to reprise Carrie pre her fabulous friendships with Miranda, Charlotte and Samantha. We came up with our own top five list that to take over for Sarah Jessica Parker that included: Miley Cyrus, Ashley Tisdale, Ashley Greene, Brittany Snow and Emma Roberts. 

Though some of you agreed with these prospects, others thought Hilary Duff would be the right gal for the job. Some other responses included: 

Kevin Tully- "Ashley tisdale!"

Jaz Heer- "I think Lauren Conrad!!!!!!"

 Shannon Riley- "Ashley Greene!"

Shanika Harvey- "I love Ashley Greene but I think Brittany Snow is a better match."

Ashley Buttercup Schilling- "I dont want a different person!"

Jamie Lynn Latham- "Emma Roberts"

Rachel Bretherton- "Ashley Tisdale! She could channel carries perkiness easily and she is the one who looks the most like a young SJP! But I agree there’s only one Carrie Bradshaw!!!!"

Lisa Marie- "I love Britney Snow. She would be absolutely fantastic for the part."

Kelly Dryden- "Blake Lively"

Rachael Bretherton- "Ashley Tisdale! She could channel carrie's perkiness ... But i agree there's only one carrie bradshaw!!!! Xxxx"

Lisa Marie- "I love Britney Snow. She would be absolutely fantastic for the part. Miley might be good for that new show...Bayou Billionaires."

Can anyone really capture the essence of this character like SJP? Can you really envision another actress in that role, even if it is the younger model? They certainly have some big Manolo Blahniks to fill! Ashley Tisdale was the winner of our Celebuzz poll by 30%, but what do you think? Cast Carrie in the comments! 



Default avatar
  • Brian Leigh
    Brian Leigh

    Hilary Duff-Carrie Emma Stone-Miranda Kristen Ruhlin- Charlotte Christine Evangelista- Samantha

  • guest

    oh so true though....they could just find a younger might even look better

  • eeee

    Dear god, no.

  • Victoria

    Thats a horrible thing to say about anybody

  • Definite

    All of these actresses are too pretty to play the part. If the actress is to look like a younger Sarah, then they will have to find someone with a badly damaged face.

  • Christina F
    Christina F

    Emma Stone!!! FOR SURE!

  • Retty

    Blake Lively would be perfect! but since she's already on another show Tisdale and Roberts are my most likely runner-ups.

  • Rebecca

    Blake Lively but she's already in Gossip Girl so...Brittany Snow or Ashley Tisdale

  • jojobabe

    blake lively

  • Margarita

    I think this should be Blake Lively

  • Connor

    Ashley Tisdale

  • Joy McBride
    Joy McBride

    Julianne Hough would be great in that part, young, perky, funny. and beautiful!


Top Stories

Get the Scoop

Sign up for the daily Celebuzz Newsletter and stay in the know.