Readers Respond! Who’s Better on ‘Men’: Ashton Kutcher or Charlie Sheen?

at 4:28 pm | By

Ashton Gets Honest
Ashton addresses honesty in the media.
Charlie Sheenhad some colorful words to say about his Two and a Half Men replacement Ashton Kutcher. The actor called in to TMZ‘s live web show on Thursday and said of Ashton: “I’m tired of lying … I’m tired of pretending the show doesn’t suck … I’m tired of pretending Ashton doesn’t suck.”

Celebuzz got an outpour of comments from our readers regarding these remarks when we asked if they thought Charlie’s comments were accurate. Is Ashton good on the hit CBS show?

Here’s what you had to say: 

Tricia Alexander– Love ashton but it really sucks.charlie sheen ws just 2 awesome.

Joann Delao Nope– he brings nothing to the show!

Angelica Aragon Rooney– The show is HORRIBLE now without Charlie. There is no point behind it now and it’s not funny or creative.

Cindi Sheehan – Sure, he’s cute to look at but he CANNOT replace our Charlie Sheen!

Debbie Benes Russell– Love Ashton – don’t miss Charlie

Kelly Zamora– “I still think its hilarious but charlie’s character was more entertaining.”

Liron Abesdid– I love Ashton, just not on two and a half men. And Charlie Sheen is the best!

Donika Kerr – I like Ashton but not for this show at all they need to get Charlie back it’s not the same with out him it was my fav show now I never watch it anymore just reruns.. I did try and watch this season but it’s not the same.

Renee Faron– I’m just happy I don’t have to see charlies white socks and loafers anymore not to mention his ugly shirts…

Who do you prefer on the show: Ashton or Charlie? Sound off in the comments, and click the pics to see Charlie’s most colorful quotes.