Readers React: Who Do You Believe - Beyonce Or the Rumors?

what do you believe?
Beyonce With Baby Blue Ivy

After Beyonce Knowles denied rumors surrounding the birth of her daughter Blue Ivy by saying they were "just crazy," Celebuzz readers proved a good conspiracy -- no matter how crazy it may seem -- is hard to dismiss.

Our readers took both sides of the issue on our Facebook page. Some sided with Bey, saying they believe her. Others weren't quite so sure. A few were determined that the 30-year-old superstar straight up propagated a fake pregnancy!

Here's a sampling of what they had to say:  

Erika L Petrie Wallace I never seen a belly uncovered so I'm not to sure I believe her but I hope it's the truth and what does it matter if she had a surrogate!

Alisha Hippiechick A ...why would she take time and enery to put on a fake belly? Why does she have to lie about whether she had a baby or not? Who came up with this stupid rumor? And last but not least if you look at beyonce baby pic ivy blue looks like her twin...seriously people need to get a life.

Melanie Ruiz I don't believe she had the baby either. The baby is healthy, that's all that matters.

Jen Spalding Not every pregnant woman feels the need to go on the cover of a magazine nude... doesn't matter either way, but considering sheep had a miscarriage before, she wasnt off telling everyone she was prego the day she found out.

Lacey Lyon I think people care because if she didn't have the baby, it would be a huge lie perpetrated on the public. People don't like being lied to. I am unsure why anyone would feel the need to cover up a surrogate anyway, maybe so the child would think it was born of Beyonce? Idk. Maybe one day there will be a clear answer.

What side are you on? Tell us in the comments below and "Like" our Facebook page to join the conversation!

Discuss

Default avatar
  • Ntombi Gumede
    Ntombi Gumede

    Nice pic

  • Nora B. Walker
    Nora B. Walker

    Belated "HAPPY 1st BTHDAY" Blue Ivy Carter!!!!!!!!!! God Bless You and your Wonderful Parents. I Love you guys and keep up the Excellent Profiles. Keep the LOVE and FIRE, Mrs. N B. Walker (A mother& Grandmother)

  • Wake Up
    Wake Up

    HOW COME PEOPLE REFUSE TO TALK ABOUT THE PREGNANCY PICS THAT WERE SNAPPED OF HER STOMACH ON VACATION IN THE WHITE BIKINI AND THE VIDEO FROM THAT VACATION AS WELL AS THE PICS IN THE BLUE BIKINI? SHE CLEARLY SHOWED HER STOMACH AS WELL AS LOOKING PREGNANT WHILE CARRYING. YOU REFUSE TO TALK ABOUT THE TRUTH BECAUSE YOUR ALL JEALOUS HATERS.

  • Kassy
    Kassy

    Have you ever heard of a surrogate? They take the guy's sperm and the girl's egg,then inject them both in the surrogate. The baby looks like Beyonce & Jay-z because the baby is 100% theirs but that doesn't mean she had they baby herself.

  • Nats
    Nats

    IT IS SOOOO OBVIOUS THAT THEY USED A SURROGATE PEOPLE OMG DIDNT U SEE THE WAY THAT BELLY FOLDED OVER?? DIDNT YOU SEE THAT SHE HADNT GAINED ANYYY WEIGHT JUST AFTER "DELIVERY"?? DIDNT YOU SEE HOW RIDICULOUS THOSE FAKE PICTURES WERE OF HER ON A WHITE BATHING SUIT?U COULD SEE HER ABS BEHIND THAT!!! OH, AND NOT TO MENTON, THE SAME DAY SHE GOT THOSE PICTURES TAKEN, WAS THE SAAAAME DAY SHE HAPPEND TO MAKE THAT VIDEO NEXT TO THAT TREE THAT MEDE THEM THINK OF THE NAME BLUE IVY! U KNOW WHY?? BOCOUSE IT IS SO DAMN HARD PUTTING THAT FAKE BELLY ON IF YOU ARE GONNA BE IN A BIKINI, THAT SHE HAD TO DO ALL THE ACTING ON THE SAME F**** DAY PEOPLE PLEASE WAKE UP ALREADY

  • chelseaf
    chelseaf

    beyonce has always been a secretive person. there was never a big stink when they got married, no one really found out until years after it happened. she's never really had media attention. why would it start now?

  • laura
    laura

    i believe my eyes and the deflating baby bump happened!

  • Misty Compton
    Misty Compton

    well it don't really matter, the baby is here and at least someone is taking care of it....but people shouldn't tell lies either, thats just plain wrong...I personally don't think that she carried and gave birth to Blue Ivy. The pictures where she was in the hospital after the birth clearly shows that she didn't even look like a women that had just previously gave birth to a baby. I don't care who you are or how much good skin you have or how much you try to make yourself look good for pictures, there is no covering up the way a woman looks after the birth of a child and even days later.

  • Wow
    Wow

    Are you people idiots? They could have used a surrogate and the baby still be theirs. I could be wrong, though I'm pretty sure it's done everyday... But doctors take the woman's egg and combine it with the man's sperm. They then implant the embryo into someone elses uterus. And BINGO you have a surrogate. Just because the Princess Diva didn't carry her ape husbands child, doesn't mean that it's not biologically theirs.

  • Olivia2
    Olivia2

    ewww!!!!! u want to me puke...kim ewww

  • Asma
    Asma

    seriously have y'all seen Blue Ivy she's like a mixture of Bey & Jay how could she create something like that,

  • Barbara Pilgrim
    Barbara Pilgrim

    I think it's her business. We're not privy to her medical records, and history, as we have no right to that information. We don't know if she can even carry a child. Either way, she has a daughter she loves. People need to focus on that. End of story.

  • Grace Gonzales
    Grace Gonzales

    Who cares. She"s a skank!!! Kim is more classy!!!

celebuzz
 

Top Stories

Get the Scoop

Sign up for the daily Celebuzz Newsletter and stay in the know.