Readers Respond: Who Would Be the Best 'X Factor' Judge -- Miley Cyrus, Demi Lovato, Avril Lavigne or Fergie?

X-Factor-Judges
Rachel Crow Talks KCAs
Rachel-Crow-Upfronts
What will she wear?! Watch »

Could one of these four ladies be sharing the judges' panel with Simon Cowell?

It certainly looks that way, because Miley Cyrus, Avril Lavigne, Fergie, and Demi Lovato are all reportedly in talks to join FOX's singing reality show competition, The X Factor. While many have been speculating that Britney Spears will be joining the judges on the show, which also includes record exec L.A. Reid, Celebuzz reported on Tuesday that the 19-year-old "Party in the USA" singer is in negotiations as well. However, there are reports that the other three singers are also being considered for the coveted job.

Celebuzz asked our Facebook readers who they thought would be right for the job, and we got some interesting responses.

Deborah O. said: the one with the most experience

Andres E. said: ‎Demi Lovato have an amazing voice and is the best in that group!!!

Anne H. said: Avril or Fergie...Miley is far too young for this job!!

What do you guys think? Keep the debate going in the comments!
Psychologist on Demi
What her body language says about her recovery. Read More »
 

Discuss

Default avatar
  • hmm
    hmm

    AVRIL LAVIGNE please :)

  • Hailey
    Hailey

    I think Miley would be the best judge. She has a lot of experience with 3 world tours, millions record sold, and shes been a mentor on American Idol before. She really does have a beautiful voice too. She is honest so she would be able to judge people without beating around the bush. Demi has an amazing voice, but not much experience, and i think she would be too sweet for the job.

  • kelluc
    kelluc

    MILEY STUPIDS :p LOL MILEY IS THE BEST!!!!!!!! i'd like Demi too :)

  • Laura
    Laura

    DEMI!!!!!!!!!!

  • Mileyrocks
    Mileyrocks

    I think Miley Cyrus because she’s not afraid to say things that might be a bit brutal + she’s had the most experience with this, being a guest on American Idol. And I love Miley!! I think Demi would be good too, but I don’t think that she would take it because she wants to focus on making music. And maybe Avril would be good because she guest stared on the show last year but I think she would be better off just guest staring

  • Dianna Johnson
    Dianna Johnson

    I'd say Fergie or Miley.

  • Ariana Schlissel
    Ariana Schlissel

    I think Miley Cyrus because she’s not afraid to say things that might be a bit brutal and she’s had the most experience with this, being a guest on American Idol. And I love Miley!! I think Demi would be good too, but I don’t think that she would take it because she wants to focus on making music. And maybe Avril would be good because she guest stared on the show last year but I think she would be better off just guest staring.

  • Ariana Schlissel
    Ariana Schlissel

    I think Miley Cyrus because she’s not afraid to say things that might be a bit brutal + she’s had experience with this, being a guest on American Idol. And I love Miley!! I think Demi would be good too, but I don’t think that she would take it because she wants to focus on making music. I don’t think Fergie or Avril would be very good.

  • Annya Nathaniel
    Annya Nathaniel

    DEMI LOVATO!

  • Rafael Gould
    Rafael Gould

    Demi Lovato or Avril Lavigne of course

  • mileyismylife
    mileyismylife

    Miley Cyrus or Demi Lovato!

  • lexi
    lexi

    of course demi has the best voice, but i don't think she would be good for the show, she would probably be the loving type and they got britney for that, i think miley is fit because she will be honest and say what she is thinking good or bad, and she is a talented singer as for avril, she wouldn't bring in a huge fan base, but talented and fergie, she can't really sing

  • o0simon0o
    o0simon0o

    I would say Demi Lovato because she have an amazing voice and a lot of experience. However, if they search someone that can handle being a celebrity pressure I would say none of them because they all changed to "fit in the box" or they had problems that being famous kind of caused or aggravated. Yes Miley's good but I don't think she could be a good judge, plus Simon Cowell seems to search to be the mean judge, Miley is saying the things like it is and it can seem brutal. Avril has a lot of experience but I think her voice isn't so deep enough to teach to some apprentice how to sing a particular note, that's my fear. Fergie's good but... I don't know, I just don't see her as a judge.

  • LBD
    LBD

    I think Miley Cyrus because she's not afraid to say things that might be a bit brutal + she's had experience with this, being a guest on American Idol. I think Demi would be good too, but I don't think that she would take it because she wants to focus on making music. I don't think Fergie or Avril would be very good.

  • Hajar Bessal
    Hajar Bessal

    I'd Totally watch it if DEMI's In It!

  • hjelm
    hjelm

    Demi Lovato of course, she has the best talent, voice and she gives great advice. Please let it be Demi.

  • petrova
    petrova

    demii

  • emmacool
    emmacool

    i dont think any of them personally but if i had to choose it would probably be Demi Lavato coz she has good experience from hollywood.

  • dumas1000
    dumas1000

    None of the above. Simon can court anyone he wants, but that doesn't mean he can deliver. Most people have a price, but I don't think Simon is going to want to meet the demands of the people on this list. It's not really worth it. I don't believe Demi would agree, no matter the price. I don't think she can be bought. Miley would demand a boatload of cash, and her heart still wouldn't be in it. Simon is smart enough to realize a bad investment when he sees one. I imagine Fergie has better things to do, although I believe she could be bought at a certain price. Avril Lavigne is not sharing a judge's table with Britney Spears. No how, no way. I still believe the best option is LeAnn Rimes. I can understand Simon shopping for a bigger fish, but LeAnn is the most likely candidate for a 4th female judge.

 
celebuzz