Though each celeb had a different take on the sweater — only one can wear it best!
Ambrosio, 31, and Simpson, 31, rocked the sweater on the Fourth of July, while Miley, 19, was spotted in the same sweater a day later. But it was Tisdale, 27, who was first spotted strolling through LAX with the slouchy style back in August 2011.
Regardless of wore it first, the starlets all seem to be pairing the casual top with denim short-shorts, with Tisdale and Cyrus looking nearly pantsless.
Which Hollywood hottie wore it better? Cast your vote in our Style Showdown and play celeb stylist in the comments!