Lady Gaga's 'Vogue' Cover Looks Like A 'Parody of Herself,' Says Body Image Expert

did 'vogue' go too far?
lady-gaga-vogue-photoshop1
Lady Gaga's Struggles
lady gaga hotel 130812
"I felt in chains at times," the singer writes in an open letter. Read More »

Vogue magazine apparently didn't get the memo that Lady Gaga was "Born This Way."

Behind-the-scenes clips of the singer's famous September issue shoot recently hit the web, and her Little Monsters have been none too pleased to see that Gaga's cover had been drastically altered.

The unearthed video footage showed Gaga with a fuller frame as she posed for the camera, suggesting that the "Edge of Glory" crooner was heavily retouched for the cover.

What kind of message does this send to Gaga's fans?

"Perhaps people feel that all's fair in love and fashion, but the Lady Gaga Vogue cover photo speaks much more that a thousand words," body image expert Dr. Robyn Silverman told Celebuzz. "Young kids may look at that photo and think, 'If even this outspoken, unique, quirky icon can't be authentically herself, what does it say about her message and what does it say about me?'"

Silverman, who's the author of Good Girls Don't Get Fat: How Weight Obsession is Messing Up Our Girls & How We Can Help Them, said Gaga's latest cover is the last straw.

"When a superstar like Gaga is known for encouraging every young person to be proud for being 'born this way,' embracing extreme Photoshopping can feel incongruent," added Silverman, who has appeared on the Today Show and Nightline.

"We need our revered celebrities to take a stand and tell the media where they must draw the line," she continued. "We all know that Photoshopping is typical, but shaving off half a person's waist, nearly eradicating her knees, shaving down the structure of her face makes Lady Gaga appear as a parody of herself rather than the symbol of authenticity and individuality she has always been known to be."

What do you think of using extreme retouching? Should it be banned in the fashion industry? Weigh in below.

 

Tags:
 

Discuss

Default avatar
  • Ray Ortega
    Ray Ortega

    Thats ridiculous. You can't ban photoshopping in the fashion industry, you estupé! First of all, this isn't Cuba. Its the USA. And if one were to look at the GIVEN assumption that US CUltural Hegemony dominants the world, then what would any fashion industry be without any photoshopping. I understand the struggles with personal identity. But frankly if "a young woman" is emulating a celebrity, then she's already got issues. This is just my opinion. And whats wrong with being thin and having issues? I mean, skinny people live longer anyway.

  • Zazazoo
    Zazazoo

    Ugly photoshopped. Extremely ugly without.

  • Tammy
    Tammy

    What do I think? Leave Gaga alone. Have some heart for this girl.

  • Aron
    Aron

    1: It's an extremely flattering angle. Women have turned slightly to the side to look thinner for ages, especially celebs. 2: It's Gaga and VOUGE, a little retouching is expected. They are both famously AND infamously known for their strives toward perfection in what they do. 3: Who's cares? It's an absolutely radiant cover and it's not like she isn't actually skinny and hot.

  • owliegrowlie
    owliegrowlie

    It seems obvious that, at least in this case, they have done these edits on purpose to deliberately make her look avant garde and otherworldly. Call it artistic license.