‘American Idol’ Premiere Recap: Ladies Lead the Pack (VIDEO)

'Idol' Alum Colton Dixon
The Season 11 finalist weighs in on the new judges.
The two-hour season premiere of American Idol delivered the deliciously good, bad, and sometimes puzzling auditions we’ve come to expect from FOX’s star-making singing competition.

After the usual wind up from host Ryan Seacrest, a montage of Season 11 winner, Philip Phillips’ whirlwind year, and footage of the new judge’s accomplishments, the first round of auditions kicked off at New York City’s Lincoln Center.

Veteran judge, Randy Jackson seemed ready to work, but before the first note had been attempted, the ladies of the panel were already sharpening their claws.

“We can have accessories, I didn’t know that was allowed,” quipped Mariah Carey at the sight of Nicki Minaj’sfeathered drum major hat.

The resulting back and forth bickering continued as the season’s first Hollywood hopeful, Michael Buonopane, entered the room to his self-made theme music of “We Will Rock You.”

His half-hearted attempt at Sean Paul’s “Temperature” failed to impress the judges, prompting the first rejection of the season. On his way out, he told Mariah that her hit, “All I Want For Christmas,” was the best Christmas song ever, prompting Nicki’s snarky response, ”Sure was, wasn’t it?” and Mariah’s quick quip, “Still is darling, 17 years later and it’s still No. 1.” Burn.

After a few more tense moments between the female judges — this time, Mariah challenged Nicki’s knowledge of the movie, Mean Girls and insisted she needed more ice — the auditions continued.

The first female to wow the judges is 28-year-old, Teena Torres of Queens, N.Y. The Camp Mariah alumni’s rendition of Carole King’s “You’ve Got a Friend” earned her this season’s first ticket to Hollywood.

Next came some snippets of some pretty impressive auditions and extremely excited panel of judges sending unnamed contestants through to Hollywood.

No Idol opener would be complete without showing some outrageously awful auditions, and this year was no exception. Case in point, 15-year-old James Bae and his painfully poor performance of Justin Bieber’s “One Less Lonely Girl” was eerily reminiscent of William Hung’s notoriously bad version of “She Bangs” on Season 3.

Christina “Isabelle” of Duluth, Ga. blew the judges away with her version of Gershwin’s “Summertime.” All four judges were impressed with her singing skills, with a super-stoked Keith Urban saying, “I think you’re a natural singer. Who did you listen to growing up? Mariah?”

Something new to auditions this season? Sob stories don’t go as far as they used to. While the judges seemed touched by Evan Ruggiero, the 21-year-old, one-legged, tap-dancing cancer survivor, they weren’t inspired enough to send him through to the next round, even after he tried two songs and pulled out a guitar.

“I like your voice, Evan. I don’t know if the star factor is there yet,” admitted Keith.

Another new twist this season is the “nomination” element where loved ones can nominate hopefuls to audition. Randy surprised Jessica Kartalis, 19, in her hometown of Staten Island and presented her with her audition number after her mother sent in a nomination. Unfortunately, her original song, “All I Ever Wanted,” was not as promising as her mother had hoped. And, she was sent packing.

While the judges seemed tough at times, other decisions were questionable. Shira Gavrielov, already had a No. 1 hit in her native Israel and released her first album at age 17. After moving to the U.S., she’s ready to revive her singing career and the judges seem inclined to help make that dream a reality as they gave her a unanimous “yes” after what seemed like a mediocre turn at Amy Winehouse’s “Valerie.” Watch her audition again above and tell us what you think.

Although 24-year-old Brooklyn native, Frankie Ford, choked during his first attempt at The Eurythmics’ “Sweet Dreams,” he took another stab at it and sealed the deal, despite shaky vocals.

“I like you. Big voice. There’s a lot of musicality,” said Urban. “I like this kid. I believe in you man,” added Jackson.

The premiere’s second hour showed Day 2 of the NYC auditions. At this point, the digs are still harmless enough, but the brewing battle between Mariah and Nicki is starting to surface.

Another wacky audition came from a wig-wearing Benjamin Gaisey, 27, who sang a medley of love songs to the ladies, including Boyz 2 Men’s hit, “I’ll Make Love To You,” clad in a red, leather tracksuit.

It was downhill from there for a while and the judges got worse and worse at disguising their disdain. “That was just bad,” Randy told one especially bad (but beautiful) contestant.

“You can study, and maybe do this as a hobby,” Mariah told another unimpressive auditioner.

Sarah Restuccio, 17, was a welcomed relief after a slew of not-so-good singers had diminished morale. She lives and works at a blueberry farm with her family in New Jersey, and wowed the female judges with Carrie Underwood’s “Mama’s Song.” “I feel like you can be an enormous country star,” noted Nicki.

Still, Randy and Keith needed some convincing, so she spit an impromptu version of Nicki’s own hit, “Superbass,” and earned herself a ticket to Hollywood.

Angela Miller, 18, saved the day when she shocked the judges with a near-perfect rendition of “Mama Knows Best” by Jessie Jdespite a severe hearing handicap. “I haven’t felt that for the whole day,” noted Nicki. Jackson agreed, calling her “the best of the day” before sending her through.

If the first round is any indication of Season 12’s prospects, this year may be one for the ladies in more ways than one. Far more females (that we saw on TV) were sent through to Hollywood. Nicki and Mariah stole the show at judge’s table and show no signs of slowing down.

Did you agree with the judges’ choices? Have the new judges reinvigorated Idol?

– Cortney Wills

Round 2 takes place at the Chicago Auditions when American Idol airs Thursday at 8PM on FOX.

Celebuzz Single Player No Autoplay (CORE)
No changes are to be made to this player