'American Idol' Recap: Final 5 Guys Round Out Top 20
It’s pretty evident why the judges are convinced a lady will win this year, as the guys’ performances paled in comparison to the ladies round.Nicki Minaj was a bit harsh on Thursday's episode and unimpressed by many of the men who took the stage. Keith Urban is still sugarcoating his critiques while Mariah Carey continues to squeeze herself into every comment. Randy Jacksonfinally claimed someone was “in it to win it” for the first time (definitely not the last) this season.
Although two of my favorite competitors took the stage, there was only one real standout moment. Overall, the vocals and the personalities were underwhelming.
So who will join last week’s list of keepers?
The only truly “amazing” moment of the night came from New Orleans native, Burnell Taylor. He first caught fans' attention after his audition brought all four judges to their feet. Since then, he has lost 40 pounds and gained a lot of confidence.
Looking a sexy school nerd complete with glasses and a bowtie, the slimmed down Southerner sings “This Time” and for a moment, I think John Legend is onstage. His voice is perfection. His delivery is captivating and absolutely the best of the night. Nicki is overjoyed and tells him, “No one else was even in your lane tonight at all, period.” He even prompted Randy to revive his signature prediction, “he’s in it to win it!” Watch it again above.
Nicki praises his consistency and authenticity and Mariah is moved, as usual, by his delivery. I’m scared the judges will do something crazy, like eliminate this gorgeous guy, but I’m wrong. (Phew!) His heart-melting story and undeniable charm earn him a seat in the Top 10.
Worship leader, Vincent Powell, is an easy pick. He’s the first contestant of the night to get the judges excited and his vocal is spot on. His gospel-tinged rendition of Lenny Williams’ “’Cause I Love You” is perfectly passionate and controlled. He’s going to Hollywood.
Nick Boddington is the final guy to get through to Hollywood and I think it’s a big mistake. I still don’t see the appeal. His voice is boring and his personality is nonexistent. I can hardly remember what he sang. His spot should have been for Bryant Tadeo who got the boot after his strong (if not a bit boring) performance of “New York State of Mind” failed to wow the panel.
The five men left standing will join Paul Jolley, Elijah Liu, Devin Velez, Charlie Askew and Curtis Finch, Jr. as they attempt to win America’s votes on the first live show next week.
What do you think of the Top 20?
Does Zoanette Johnson belong in the Top 20? Watch her performance again below.