We Think We Spy a Lady Gaga in the ‘American Horror Story’ Season 6 Promo

The trailer for the remainder of this season of American Horror Story debuted on Wednesday (Sept. 14, 2016) and the internet might have found a snippet of Lady Gaga’s alleged appearance, but if it isn’t, we can call it a “Perfect Illusion.”

American Horror Story: My Roanoke Nightmare will play out as a mockumentary focused on the 1590 mystery of Roanoke, a colony of North Carolina, which disappeared when 117 people vanished without explanation. So far, the main characters are Shelby and Matt, who move to Roanoke Island from Los Angeles after Matt encounters a near-death experience and Shelby miscarries. They are portrayed in “real life” by Lily Rabe and Andre Holland while Sarah Paulson and Cuba Gooding Jr. serve as the characters’ reenactors. Angela Bassett is Lee, a cop from the area who’s been through it after shooting a man in the line of duty, losing custody of her child, and developing a dependence on pills. Adina Porter takes on Bassett’s character’s role in the talking head segments.

The first episode leads to a final scene when Shelby encounters the lost inhabitants of Roanoke, one of whom is portrayed by Kathy Bates. Rumored returns of Matt Bomer, Evan Peters, and Lady Gaga have yet to play out in the season, but fans of Gaga are convinced that this is her in the second episode’s promo that was released after the premiere:


Stefani? That you, girl???


Take a look at the new trailer below and see if you can figure out what’s actually happening. American Horror Story airs on Wednesdays at 10 p.m. on FX.