WATCH: Jon Hamm Wants to Know If You’d Have a Threesome with Him and Billy Eichner

Women may be falling over themselves for Don Draper, but it’s a whole different story when it comes to Jon Hamm.

In a preview for the Season 5 premiere of Billy on the Street, the Mad Men star joins host Billy Eichner to ask New Yorkers if they’d have a threesome with the two of them (for a dollar — natch). Unfortunately for Hamm, not a lot of people took up them on the offers.

Despite finally winning that elusive Emmy after seven — seven! — tries, many still weren’t impressed with the actor. Clearly, none of them saw these photos of Hamm wearing tight pants.

“He doesn’t have an Oscar though,” one passerby quipped before turning the duo down.

“I know he doesn’t have great buzz at the moment, but he’s still a handsome fellow,” Eichner argued with another woman who was hesitant about taking the offer. “A threesome with 2016 Billy Eichner but 2009 Jon Hamm, yes?”

However, the biggest challenge for the twosome was perhaps figuring out who would be on top when they did find someone who took them up on the deal.

“We know you’re a bottom,” Eichner told Hamm, hinting that his onscreen ex-wife may have let the cat out of the bag. “I’ve spoken to January Jones.”

Billy on the Street’s fifth season premieres on Nov. 15 at 10:30 ET on TruTV.