Jeremy Davies’ Emmy win shocked just about everyone at the Creative Arts Emmys on Saturday, including the actor himself.

“I met the great, great Michael J. Fox at rehearsals yesterday … I really thought, if anyone amongst the equally brilliant individuals nominated alongside me, I thought it would go to him,” the actor, who won Outstanding Guest Actor in a Drama Series for his chilling performance on the FX drama Justified, revealed to Celebuzz.

“Look at me. Does this look right? What’s wrong with this picture?” he quipped.

“I want to reassure you that I reported the robbery properly.”

Still, that didn’t stop the actor, who was nominated in the same category last year, from doing a little celebrating.

So, who was the first person he called after he won?

“I actually called my sister, my sister Katie,” he said. “She was stratospherically overjoyed.”

For more on Davies’ win — and the chance to see him mingle with, of all people, James Van Der Beek, watch the video, above.