Personally just hotness alone, nhoting else, not the acting ability, or self-confidence, or anything else, just based on who is hotter, it is definitely the Twilight guys. I personally thing the story is better with Hunger Games, but lets face facts Robert is to cool for school. He is so charismatic, just a smirk from him brings women and girls to their knees (no pun intended), Josh does not have that ability in my opinion and althougth I think Liam is cuter of the two, he still can't compare to Robert's charisma. I do agree I wish they would stop comparing them, it is like comparing apples against oranges, they are two completely different generes. It is so idiotic.