Season 1, Episode 19: "A Person of Interest"
Spence and Toby made the jump to more than friends towards the end of Season 1. Under investigation for Alison’s murder and certain that his step-sister Jenna is staying at the Rosewood motel, Spencer and Toby decide to stake out her room and end up spending the night together listening through the wall and playing scrabble. After the two realize they were duped by “A”, they share their first kiss in the parking lot.
It’s no secret that Ryan Reynolds is ridiculously good-looking.
Taylor Swift might not approve…