‘Pretty Little Liars': Our Top 5 ‘Spoby’ Moments
Season 2, Episode 12: "Over My Dead Body"
When “A” sends a message, Spence listens. After receiving a creepy doll telling her to “Keep Toby safe” shortly after the brakes on his truck malfunction, she breaks up with Toby in where else but his truck. Realizing that everyone she loves gets hurt because of her tormentor she decides to break things off with him. Toby also yells "I love you" to her at the police station after she and the other Liars are arrested for Ali's murder.