Actually as boxers punch they turn the thumb down so that the shoulder protects the face. So By counter punching I mean Oliver had to strike first to get hit in the shoulder. If U deflect a punch it will not hit U in the shoulder.I wish I was the lawyer on this case. Such an easy easy win. When the smoke settles if Gabe can prove this was a set up he can sue for emotional distress and prove that Halle is an irresponsible parent maeaning he should get custody and the beech has to pay him child support.