Legend star Will Smith showed up on David Letterman looking all pumped up for his latest role as a reluctant superhero in Hancock, co-starring Charlize Theron. The Ali actor’s sculpted physique proved to be too much for the gushing talk show host.

“Every time I see you, you just look better and better,” Dave told a smiling Will. The two then shared air kisses to the cheek, initiated by Smith, who exclaimed over a cheering audience, “Once you go black, you never go back, Dave.” Hmm, whatever could he be referring to?

As awkwardly homoerotic as the situation might have been, you know Dave was just happy not to be stuck interviewing this douche again. Although, to be fair, the douche did make Letterman laugh.