‘American Idol’ Brings Back Jermaine Jones: Was He the Right Choice? (POLL)

at 8:49 am | By

Where are 'Idol' Alums?
From Kelly to Carrie, what's up with the 'AI' alumni?
JLO & Casper Smooch!
Jennifer Lopez kisses her new beau.
Last week, American Idol teased that it would bring back one of four guys for the first live performance of season 11: Jermaine Jones, Richie Law, David Leathers Jr. or Johnny Keyser.

Well, last night we found out its choice, when Jermaine Jones returned to the Idol stage one more time to sing Luther Vandross’ Dance With My Father – a somewhat fitting choice for a man looking for a second chance.

Jermaine, an extremely tall, lovable contestant, was obviously a big hit with the judges. But did the show bring back the right contestant? And should they have brought back anyone at all? Vote now in our poll!